Skip to main content

Twelfth meeting of the Task Force on Access to Justice under the Aarhus Convention

28 February - 01 March 2019
Salle VII, Palais des Nations Geneva Switzerland

The twelfth meeting of the Task Force on Access to Justice  took place from 28 February 2019 (afternoon) to 1 March 2019 in Geneva (Palais des Nations, Building A, Salle VII).

The meeting aimed to provide a platform for exchanging information, experiences and good practices with regard to key recent developments in the implementation of the Convention’s pillar on access to justice and possible measures to remove barriers hampering its implementation. It thereby supported the implementation of environmental dimension of Sustainable Development Goals, in particular Sustainable Development Goal 16 and its target 16.3 (Promote the rule of law at the national and international levels and ensure equal access to justice for all)  that undergo in-depth review in 2019 .

The thematic session of the meeting focused on access to justice in cases relating to air quality. The Task Force identified good practices, barriers, challenges, innovative approaches, priority actions and needs to promote effective access to justice in such cases thereby also supporting the attainment of Sustainable Development Goals 3, 11 and 12. In addition, delegates continued the discussion on measures to promote effective access to justice in cases on the right to environmental information based on the preliminary findings of the survey launched at the previous meeting. Delegates also had an opportunity to share information other new developments related to the implementation of the third pillar of the Convention and examined tools to promote effective access to justice.

Hashtags for the meeting: @UNECEAarhus, #AarhusConvention, #AccesstoJustice, #CleanAir, #CleanerAir, #AirQuality, #AirPollution, #EnvironmentalRights, #Right2info, #SDG16

The meeting preceded by 2019 Judicial Colloquium (Geneva, 27-28 (morning) February 2019) for representatives of judiciary, judicial training institutions and other review bodies.

For more information about the meetings, please read here

Documents

Provisional agenda and documents for the meeting are available below.

The background material for the meeting includes relevant information derived from 2017 national implementation reports and the 2017 synthesis report as well as the Convention’s Implementation Guide, relevant Compliance Committee findings of a systemic nature, the analytical studies and the jurisprudence database developed under auspices of the Task Force.

 

Document title ENG FRE RUS
Provisional Agenda (AC/TF.AJ-12/Inf.1) PDF    
Report PDF PDF PDF
List of speakers (AC/TF.AJ-12/Inf.1/Add.1) PDF    
List of outcomes (AC/TF.AJ-12/Inf.5) PDF    
Report PDF    
List of participants PDF    
Item 2. Thematic focus: Access to justice in cases relating to air quality      
2019 Report of the UN Special Rapporteur on Human Rights and the Environment      
Item 3. Follow up to the previous thematic session on access to justice in cases on the right to environmental information      
All relevant information available in the next tab “AJAI study”      
Item 4. Stocktaking of recent and upcoming developments       
Overview of the implementation of article 9 of the Convention regarding encountered challenges (AC/TF.AJ-12/Inf.2) PDF    
Selected considerations, findings and reports of the Aarhus Convention Compliance Committee - article 9, paragraph 1 (AC/TF.AJ-11/Inf.3) PDF    
Selected considerations, findings and reports of the Aarhus Convention Compliance Committee - article 9, paragraphs 2-5 (AC/TF.AJ-12/Inf.3) PDF    
Statement by Environment Links UK on access to justice in UK 2019 PDF    
Item 5. Tools to promote effective access to justice      
Overview of the availability of the quantitative data (AC/TF.AJ-12/Inf.4) PDF    

Statements and Presentations

Title ENG FRE RUS
Item 2. Thematic focus: Access to justice in cases relating to air quality.      
(a) Setting the scene      
Mr. David BOYD, Special Rapporteur on Human Rights and the Environment (video-message)      
Ms. Albena KARADJOVA, Secretary to the UNECE Convention on Long-range Transboundary Air Pollution PDF    
(b) Experience in the European Union      
Mr. Daniele FRANZONE, Senior Expert, European Commission PDF    
Mr. Ugo TADDEI, ClientEarth PDF    
(c) Experience in individual Parties to the Convention      
Mr. Joost PIKKEMAAT, Senior Legal Counsel, Ministry of Infrastructure and Water management, the Netherlands PDF    
Mr. Daniel LAMFRIED, Research Assistant, Environment Agency, Germany PDF    
Mr. Aidos ZHAKIYALIN, Head of the Department, General Prosecutor’s Office, Kazakhstan PDF    
Ms. Regina STOILOVA, Environmental Association Za Zemiata PDF    
Mr. Pavel ČERNÝ, Frank Bold Society PDF
PDF
   
Item 3. Follow up to the previous thematic session on access to justice in cases on the right to environmental information.      
(a) Progress report on the survey      
Mr. Jan DARPO, Chair of the Task Force on Access to Justice PDF    
(b) Recent developments      
Ms. Edlira DERSHA, Statistic Officer, Ministry of Tourism and the Environment, Albania PDF    
Ms. Melanie CAMPBELL, Investigator, Office of the Commissioner for Environmental Information, Ireland PDF    
Mr. Thomas SCHOMERUS, Professor, Leuphana University, Germany PDF    
Item 4. Stocktaking of recent and upcoming developments.      
(a) International level      
Ms. Angela KARIUKI, Programme Management Officer, United Nations Environment Programme PDF    
(c) Addressing existing challenges      
Mr. Plamen PEEV, Bluelink Foundation and Justice and Environment PDF    
Ms. Sofyia SHUTIAK, Environment-People-Law PDF    
Ms. Mari CHAKRYAN, Public Awareness and Monitoring Centre PDF    
Item 5. Tools to promote effective access to justice.      
(a) Monitoring the effectiveness of justice      
Ms. Tsvetelina FILIPOVA, Senior Policy Analyst, Institute for European Environmental Policy PDF    
Mr. Plamen PEEV, Bluelink Foundation and Justice and Environment PDF    
(b) Judicial cooperation      
Justice Anders BENGTSSON, Land and Environment Court Växjö, Sweden and the Association of European Administrative Judges PDF    
Justice Beibut SHERMUKHAMETOV, Supreme Court, Kazakhstan PDF   PDF

 

AJAI study

Study on access to justice in information cases

Pursuant to decision VI/3, para. 14 (a) (i), of the Meeting of the Parties to the Convention, the Task Force on Access to Justice at its 11th meeting (Geneva, 27-28 February 2018) agreed to prepare a study on access to justice in information cases.

To gather the required information, a survey was carried out among several institutions dealing with this subject in the selected Parties, namely in Georgia, European Union, Germany, Ireland, Kazakhstan, Montenegro, Portugal, the Republic of Moldova, Serbia, Slovakia, Sweden and Switzerland.  The draft report by the Chair of the Task Force was then prepared summarizing the responses received to the survey. The report provided a basis for the discussion at the 12th meeting of the Task Force on Access to Justice (Geneva, 28 February – 1 March 2019).

The draft report was further revised by the Chair in the light of the comments made at the  12th meeting of the Task Force and comments submitted to the secretariat after the meeting.

The present draft report is made available for comments by the Aarhus Convention national focal points and stakeholders (see the revised draft report (v. 29 July 2020) in the table below). The comments should be sent to the secretariat (aarhus.survey[at]un.org) by 1 November 2020. The receipt of the comments will be acknowledged by the secretariat and they will be made available online in the table below.

Following this round of consultations, the final text of the report will discussed and finalized  at the next meeting of the Task Force on Access to Justice in 2021.

Documents

Title ENG FRE RUS
Questionnaire on access to justice in cases on the right to environmental information (AC/TF.AJ-11/Inf.4 (final)) PDF    
Responses received to the above Chair      
Draft report by the Chair (v. 22 February 2019 ) discussed at the 12TFAJ meeting PDF    
Revised draft report by the Chair (v. 29 January 2020)  DOC    
Comments received on the draft report by the Chair      
Revised draft report by the Chair (v.29 July 2020) for comments by 1 November 2020 DOC