Case status: Pending.
Follow-up: -
Topics: Access to justice.
Articles alleged: 9 (3).
Articles considered by the Committee: -
Articles, if any, found in non-compliance: -
Summary: The communication was submitted to the Compliance Committee by the NGO ClientEarth on 27 October 2016. The communication alleged non-compliance with article 9 (3) of the Convention in relation to access to justice to challenge local laws that contravened national law relating to the environment.
| Documents | Status | Date received or posted by the secretariat |
|---|---|---|
|
Communication |
From the communicant | 27.10.2016 |
| Annex 6: English translation of certain provisions of Polish law Annex 7: Judgment I OSK 2143_11 POL Annex 8: Judgment I OSK 2236_12 POL Annex 9: Judgment II SA_Bk 507_13 POL Annex 10: Judgment I OSK 1659_15 POL Annex 11: Business register POL |
||
| Questions to the communicant from the Chair and Vice-Chair of the Committee | From the secretariat | 15.11.2017 |
| Reply to Committee’s questions Annex 1: Supreme Administrative Court judgment no. II OSK 1539/09, 18.12.2009 ENG Annex 2: Supreme Administrative Court judgment no. II OSK 510/14, 30.07.2015 ENG Annex 3: Regional Administrative Court judgment no. II/SA/Wr 383/17, 05.09.2017 ENG |
From the communicant | 26.01.2018 |
| Annex 4: Supreme Administrative Court judgment no. II/OSK 1282/15, 15.02.2017 ENG Annex 5: Supreme Administrative Court judgment no. II OSK 2671/16, 29.11.2017 ENG Annex 6: Provincial Administrative Court Gliwice judgment no. II SA/Gl 639/17, 15.09.2017 ENG |
||
| Email enclosing judgement I OSK 3218.17 ENG POL | From the communicant | 05.03.2018 |
| Letters to the Party concerned and the communicant enclosing Committee's determination of preliminary admissibility and forwarding the communication for the Party concerned's response | From the secretariat | 22.03.2018 |
| Response to communication | From the Party concerned | 22.08.2018 |
| Comments on Party concerned's response | From the communicant | 31.10.2018 |
| Letter seeking the parties’ views on whether they consider there are reasons for not considering communications ACCC/C/2016/151, ACCC/C/2017/154 and ACCC/C/2018/158 jointly | From the secretariat | 21.06.2019 |
| Letter regarding whether there are reasons for not considering communications ACCC/C/2016/151, ACCC/C/2017/154, and ACCC/C/2018/158 jointly | From the Party concerned | 18.07.2019 |
| Reply to Committee’s letter providing its views as to whether there are reasons for not considering communications ACCC/C/2016/151, ACCC/C/2017/154, and ACCC/C/2018/158 jointly | From the communicant | 18.07.2019 |
| Update | From the communicant | 21.02.2022 |
| Letter explaining how the Committee will proceed with respect to communications ACCC/C/2016/151, ACCC/C/2017/154, ACCC/C/2018/158 | From the secretariat | 28.03.2022 |
| Letters inviting Party concerned and communicants of communications ACCC/C/2016/151, ACCC/C/2017/154 and ACCC/C/2018/158 to joint hearing at the Committee’s 75th meeting | From the secretariat | 05.04.2022 |
| Letter enclosing questions from the Committee to the parties | From the secretariat | 04.05.2022 |
| Reply to the Committee’s questions Annexes 1-14 |
From the communicant | 31.05.2022 |
| Cover letter enclosing reply to Committee’s questions ENG POL Annex 1: Relevant provisions |
From the Party concerned | 08.06.2022 (dated 07.06.2022) |
| Opening statement for the joint hearing on communications ACCC/C/2016/151, ACCC/C/2017/154 and ACCC/C/2018/158 | From the Party concerned | 16.06.2022 |
| Opening statement for the hearing on communications ACCC/C/2016/151 and ACCC/C/2017/154 | From the communicant | 16.06.2022 |
| Joint statement delivered at hearing on communications ACCC/C/2016/151, ACCC/C/2017/154 and ACCC/C/2018/158 | From the Party concerned | 27.06.2022 |
| Cover email enclosing letter ENG POL | From the Party concerned | 10.11.2022 |